The Paradox of Choice indeed. With so many gloves to choose from, where does one begin? Options are wide, ranging from inexpensive multi-packs to gloves made from the finest Corinthian – er, Premium Cabretta leather. And just what is this Cabretta leather? Well, it’s produced from the skins of sheep that have hair instead of wool (straight-haired sheepskins). And what makes them Premium? Marketing.
It would be one expensive proposition for a player to purchase a handful of the finest (read: $$$$) gloves, so I’ve made it less expensive (read: free) for you. At retail prices hitting $30, some may wonder if gloves matter at all, and if so, does the brand and model? Heck, there are professionals that compete without gloves, including Fred Couples and Lucas Glover. As for me, I need to keep these babies nice and soft for my other job as a hand model.
Read on for my impressions of four of the top premium golf gloves on the market from Bionic, FootJoy, Hirzl, and Titleist.
Bionic PerformanceGrip
Retail price: $29.95
Amazon.com: Check price now
The Bionic family of gloves stands out in its looks – if you’ve spent time browsing the aisles at your local golf retailer, this one likely caught your eye. It’s not just the green and blue packaging, it’s the glove that looks most like one you might find at batting practice. I wasn’t surprised, then, to find out that Bionic is a part of the Louisville Slugger family of products. It also might have stood out to you with the nearly $30 retail price, the first golf glove to approach this barrier (the FootJoy Pure Touch, below, was more recently the first to hit it).
The glove is designed by an orthopedic hand surgeon, and the feature most heavily promoted and quickly noticed is its “Triple-Row Finger Grip System”. Or as I like to call it at cocktail parties, TRFGS. This, simply put, is additional padding at certain points in the fingers of the glove (yes, this conforms to USGA Rules) to even out the “valleys” in your fingers opposite your knuckles. The theory behind this design is that the additional padding will distribute the pressure across your full finger, instead of just certain points, resulting in better grip of the club without needing to grip harder and, consequently, fewer blisters and callouses. Combine this padding with the 15 mini-Terrycloth towels that are sewn into the glove throughout the front of the hand that help absorb perspiration, and I could definitely sense additional material between my hand and grip as soon as I put it on.
Beyond the padding and Terrycloth, the Bionic PerformanceGrip also has more flexible fabric than any other golf glove with lycra in between the fingers, on all knuckles, the back of the hand, and the palm – a whopping 26 different areas! As with some other premium gloves, the glove is cut to follow your fingers as they rotate inward toward the center of your hand when gripping. In addition, there are four pieces of elastic (plus another around the wrist) on the back of the hand. This all results in a glove that has exceptional fit and flexibility, but with so many components that have been stitched together, feels decidedly non-traditional. I found myself gradually getting used to the Bionic, although every time I slipped it on I could still tell I was putting on a glove of a different breed. I can’t say that it helped or hindered my ability to feel the club or the ball, but neither did I notice any difference in how fatigued my hand would be after a round or any real reduction in blisters and callouses (I have a few small seemingly permanent callouses, so it was somewhat tough to tell in this regard). Despite the significant amount of both stitching and material, the glove is still machine-washable.
While the glove is undeniably flexible and fit the contours of my hand arguably better than any other glove on the market while gripping a club, I am simply too conditioned to want only the thinnest and softest leather between my hand and the club. This glove will work best for players that could stand to grip their clubs more lightly, and also should be considered by those who haven’t been able to find gloves with quite the right fit – the lycra portions of the club may well help. The Terrycloth interior towels and breathable lycra also make this a glove that players in the warmest climates may wish to consider (we haven’t played in extreme heat with the Bionic). Although the Bionic PerformanceGrip has “top-grade” Cabretta leather, it isn’t as soft as the other high-end gloves tested. Then again, that isn’t the goal or selling point of this glove.
At $29.95 retail, the Bionic PerformanceGrip is the second-highest priced glove we reviewed (just a nickel behind the FootJoy Pure Touch Limited). This is a serious price for a glove I consider more of a curiosity than anything else. Is it worth trying? Possibly, but my guess is that this glove is going to appeal to only a fraction of the players out there, and adoption will likely be hindered by a combination of the different feel as well as the high price tag.
FootJoy Pure Touch Limited
Retail price: $30
Amazon.com: Check price now
What I primarily look for in a glove is comfort and feel. Secondary in my search is a glove that is extremely durable and breathable – I don’t wear through gloves fast enough to place a premium on durability nor do I play in extreme heat. For my wants, the FootJoy Pure Touch Limited tops my list.
In terms of design, it is one of the simplest. The glove is made early entirely of “Exclusive Select Cabretta leather” (makes you wonder why it isn’t Premium or Top-Grade, doesn’t it?) with a soft feel that they is achieved through “proprietary leather preparation techniques” (how mysterious!). It’s very traditional, with no lycra sewn into the back (or front) of the glove or between the fingers, and certainly not a hint of Terrycloth to be found. There are three bands of elastic that runs across the back of the hand, and some elastic around the wrist to provide a snug fit.
The FootJoy Pure Touch Limited is, as the name implies, not available widely. I was able to find them at my local retail store, though very few were available. My best guess is that FootJoy is testing the waters with the Limited to see what demand there is for a glove that, hold on to your hats, has an MSRP of $30. Though I like playing with this glove, at $30 it starts to make me consider whether another glove in the FootJoy line is “good enough” (such as the FootJoy StaSof, which retails for $24). Is it worth the extra $6? In terms of softness and fit, it was the softest glove in the group (though yes, we are operating at the margins now). And though it is “Limited”, your friends aren’t going to give you credit for playing this glove unless you make a spectacle of pulling it from its all-black packaging (hey, the black separates the elite credit cards from the rest, so maybe it can apply to golf glove packaging as well). They might even make fun of you when you try to store it in its packaging, which requires stuffing the glove down the top of its envelope (imagine an envelope that opens at the “end”, instead of opening on the side, which is much simpler to access).
Lacking any additional materials that detract from the supple leather, and without perforation on the front of the fingers, the glove is perceptibly soft. The downside is, of course, that you may not achieve the level of fit that comes with gloves that have sections of lycra, and you won’t have the breathability that comes with either lycra or additional perforations. But my bet is that people who purchase this glove will treat it nicely to maintain it (no stuffing it into the bottom of your golf bag after sweating through 18 holes on a hot day) and likely not mind rotating gloves more quickly than they would with a different glove. When the time comes though, this glove is machine washable.
The sheer softness of the glove make the FootJoy Pure Touch Limited my favorite of the group, but I still struggle to process the price tag. If I go through four gloves in a season (I’m not noticing any more wear to this glove than the competition), we are talking about $24 more dollars versus other premium gloves for the year. Am I trying to rationalize my decision to buy them in the future? Absolutely. It’s not going to break my bank account, but a penny saved…
Hirzl Soffft Flex
Retail price: $28.99
Amazon.com: Check price now
The newest glove company to enter the game is Hirzl, manufacturers of golf and cycling gloves out of…Switzerland! The company has bypassed the crowded market of lower-priced gloves and jumped into the high-end market. From the Hirzl line I selected their Soffft Flex to stack up in our review. And yes, that’s “Soffft” with 3 f’s. Out of the gate I’m going to make a personal plea for all marketing teams to stop branding their products in either all-caps or made-up words. Seriously how many people will differentiate between Soft Flex, Sofft Flex and Soffft Flex. Of course, the joke will be on me when next year’s model is called the Sofffft Flex.
The Hirzl Soffft Flex is made of the “highest quality Platinum” (Platinum? Huh?) “new generation cabretta” (Does that mean it is made from younger sheep in the same family of sheep that have produced other gloves?), with perforations on the front and back of the fingers, and one piece of lycra that runs across the knuckles on the back of the hand along with four pieces of elastic just below the lycra strip as well as at the wrist. The combination of lycra and elastic make for a glove that fits better than gloves with elastic bands only (the lycra removing much of the tension in the glove that occurs when gripping a club). Not a huge difference, but it is discernable. The Hirzl Soffft, as with the competition, features a pre-curved finger design.
Backing up the name, the glove is indeed soft. In the Critical Golf Double-Blind Glove-Feeling test, the Soffft rated just behind the FootJoy Players glove in overall softness. Want to know why it’s so soft? I’ll tell you the secret: it is their production formula based upon a tetra tanning process (sshhh, don’t tell!). I haven’t been able to tell any difference in wear of this glove versus the others tested, nor can I tell any difference in durability. While I haven’t played in extreme heat in this glove, I would expect the lycra and perforations will keep perspiration down slightly compared to the FootJoy Pure Touch glove (though if you get too sweaty or dirty, the glove can be machine washed).
But hey, maybe you don’t believe me and want some charts and graphs. “Show me the data!” Hirzl is happy to oblige (see images at right). Clearly these gloves show both unsurpassed dimensional stability (though only tested using artificial perspiration, natch), and unsurpassed tear strength as tested by the Baumann Tear Strength Method. Our Critical Golf Tear Strength Method (which involved the glove and our dog) was inconclusive.
At $28.99 retail, the Hirzl Soffft Flex straddles the line between the high-end gloves of the recent past, and the latest ones that push the $30 barrier. The restrained use of lycra makes for a glove that provides a great fit while maintaining a reasonably traditional look. If players don’t have any qualms with using a new brand on the market, I think they could fall for this glove.
Titleist Players
Retail price: $24
Amazon.com: Check price now
The Titleist Players Glove is the least expensive in this bunch, at a reasonable sounding $24 that is, yes, still probably 8 times more than my grandfather would have found acceptable to pay for a golf glove. While the price is low, Titleist keeps up with the competition in marketing, with the “thinnest leather specification” due to “premium selected, soft, thin skins” which phrasing, truthfully, makes me feel somewhat guilty about not using a synthetic glove.
The glove is a traditional Titleist cabretta glove – extremely soft, perforated at the front and back of the fingers, with three elastic bands at the back of the hand plus one around the wrist to provide a good fit. Unlike the competition, and maybe to Titleist’s detriment, it comes in the same style packaging as the rest of the line, which very well make players pass on this glove due to the relative price versus others in the Titleist family.
There isn’t too much to say about this glove. It’s one of the best around, and absolutely worthy of consideration. It lacks the lycra of some gloves, but still provides decent breathability and a fit that will satisfy most players. The stitching at the base of the thumb is different than the other gloves (who notices THAT?), with the stitches on the inside of the glove, as opposed to the other gloves where you can see the stitching on the outside (I am sure there is some technical term for this style of stitching, but I don’t know what it is). This results in a seam you can feel a bit more than other gloves, though it’s barely discernible. Why the difference in construction, I have not a clue. And no, this isn’t a big deal, just a difference.
At up to 20% less expensive than others in this group, The Titleist Players glove is a logical choice for players that are looking for a premium glove that doesn’t break the bank (as much as another $6 can break the bank). It’s all about what you get for your money, however, and at $24 it does fall into the next “class of glove”, with a gap between it and the $18 Titleist Prema Soft Glove. It is an exceptional glove however, and if you are looking to spring for one of the best golf gloves on the market, give it a look.
Maybe I’m just old fashioned, but when I spend $18 I still think I should get an exceptionally soft glove that fits well. And truth be told, I can. What you get for the additional $6-12 is, depending on the glove, one that perhaps fits better, is that much softer, or performs better in the heat than others. The difference in these gloves is absolutely at the margins, however, so we’ll leave it to others to determine the incremental benefits from these top-tier gloves.
Whatever you choose, no benzene-based detergents when washing these gloves, ok?
Have thoughts on these gloves or your favorites? Let us know.
Funny thing: I was visiting my parents house about a year ago, and found an old FootJoy Stasof glove from about 15 yrs ago, unused and in new condition. It looks, feels and fits like the “Pure Touch Limited”.
Personally, I don’t mind spending some $$$ for a glove, because I feel it’s an overlooked part of golf equipment that helps with the only part of the body that has a direct connection to the club. Is it gonna shave 5 strokes off you game? Of course not, but neither is that latest and greatest $500 driver, even if it does add 30 yds.
However, in my experience, the ‘midrange’ gloves these days, like the StaSof line, etc., perform just fine, and are definitely more than ‘good enough’. Agree that the difference is marginal, unlike the difference between a lower end glove and a midrange glove, which is dramatic.